Protests at Gallaudet, the premiere univeristy for the education of deaf and hard-of-hearing individuals, reached a head this weekend with the arrest of 133 protesters. Why are they protesting? That's unclear based on recent articles. Either the newspapers or the protesters are doing a bad job at communicating what is so abhorrent about Fernandes to the Gallaudet community. Fernandes, who grew up deaf in a speaking environment and did not learn ASL until the age of 23, says she's "not deaf enough" for the students. The students and faculty claim that Fernandes lacks "leadership qualities." This NYT article from last spring is a good primer on the issues at Gallaudet.
Fernandes want to make Gallaudet more accomodating to all individuals with hearing impairments, not just members of the Deaf community. As a member of the hearing community, this strikes me as a reasonable approach given that we are in an era where technology is changing deafness. Fernandes has also been criticized for not banning students from speaking to each other in front of deaf students. Assuming that deafness is a cultural identity, I view banning speaking between students at Gallaudet as analogous to another university banning Chinese students from speaking Chinese with each other. I sympatize with the students and faculty of Gallaudet, because cultural shifts can be hard and, as institutions change, it often feels like something has been lost.
Though I have always loathed serious college activists (preferring Stephenson's inactivists, fighting for the right to do, ehhh, you know...) and hate to see them win, I can't see any course of action other than Fernandes' resignation. While I find the arguments from protestors about Fernandes' lack of leadership rather nebulous, five months of increasingly volatile protests is a pretty clear statement on her inability to lead Gallaudet.
Note: The headline quote comes from this WaPo article. In addition, most of these thoughts are based on mainstream media articles, the iaccuracy and mpartiality of which has been disputed. Here's an informative blog post about the protests.
hellx said:
It's dancing at the Swazi cultural village. As I get more photos from my mom/dad/sister, I'll add them to glimpse.Mr. Guapo said:
Properly speaking, is that an Afro? I don't think so.Mr. Guapo said:
Hello Brooklyn!Mr. Guapo said:
Extremely cool. Dig the Chuck T's on the guy to her left. What's the story behind this one? Also, we need more photos for the blog on the left.doubleohsoul said:
We just went to a Devotchka show over the weekend, playing with Norfolk and Western. N& W has kind of an alt-country feel, Devotchka more of a gypsy kind of thing, but they're from Colorado. They opened with Venus in Furs by V.U. (I thought, these guys are kind of ripping of the Velvets, what withMembers' Blogs
Sparkling Squirrel Year
• Plantnerd
Bag O' Glass
• TSI!
Pedimobility
• Thinman
Exercise Before Knitting *
• Elinor
Welcome to Oz
• Mrs. Soul
Powered by MT Blogroll
* denotes a recently updated blog
Recent Posts
Archives
[What is this?]